Federal prosecutors this week revealed numerous details about the cause of a Jan. 1 fire in Pacific Palisades that six days later flared to life as the Palisades Fire.
The federal investigation made it possible to draw two major conclusions:
Many questions remain unanswered and are likely to resurface in the days and weeks to come. The question arises: what is Rinderknecht’s alleged motive and how did he actually start the fire? The second is whether firefighters could have done more to prevent the January 1 fire from reigniting on January 7.
“The arsonist started the first fire, but firefighters have a duty to do some things proactively,” said Ed Nordskog, former chief of the Los Angeles County sheriff’s arson unit and arson profiler.
Here’s a look at what we know and don’t know:
Court documents present extensive evidence that prosecutors say shows Rinderknecht was on the hiking trail in the early hours of New Year’s Day when the fire broke out. They include:
Acting U.S. Atty. Bill Essayli speaks as Los Angeles Police Chief Jim McDonnell, right, looks on during a news conference Wednesday announcing the arrest of Jonathan Rinderknecht, 29.
(Christina House / Los Angeles Times)
Federal prosecutors refused to list a formal motive. But in a press conference and in court documents, they shared several details about his behavior just before and immediately after the fire started.
Prosecutors plan to present their evidence to a grand jury and have said more details – and the charges – could then be revealed.
“They still haven’t gotten a grand jury indictment, so they may add charges. The complaint is just to arrest him and take him to Los Angeles,” said Neama Rahmani, a former federal prosecutor.
A clear motive is one thing. But another question is how exactly he started the fire.
A helicopter drops water Jan. 8 near the village of Topanga, along Topanga Canyon Road.
(Genaro Molina/Los Angeles Times)
The federal report says Los Angeles firefighters thought they had extinguished the Jan. 1 fire. But when high winds hit on January 7, the fire reignited and ravaged Pacific Palisades.
Some residents criticized why firefighters did not put out the initial fire and why they did not deploy engines to the area before the high winds predicted on January 7.
ATF Special Agent in Charge Kenny Cooper placed the blame squarely on Rinderknecht.
“The Los Angeles City Fire first responded and extinguished the fire, then that fire burned deep into the ground, into the roots and into the structure, and remained active for several days. Once the catastrophic winds picked up, the fire needed fuel, oxygen and heat,” he said.
“The person who started this fire is the one responsible. I will never blame our brave firefighters when we know how this fire started,” he added.
But some experts say more scrutiny is needed on firefighters’ tactics.
“This affidavit puts the onus on the firefighters. There needs to be a commission looking into why this reignited fire was allowed to reignite,” Nordskog said.
The ATF offered a modest account of how firefighters battled the Jan. 1 blaze. But it didn’t contain many details about what the department did or didn’t do to ensure the fire was actually put out.
Fires that reignite days or weeks after a wildfire has been extinguished are not common. Most often, a recovery occurs when firefighters are still on the scene cleaning up, allowing them to take control quickly, a fire expert told The Times in January. There are steps firefighters can take to prevent this.
Tim BontempsOctober 9, 2025, 11:46 a.m. ETCloseTim Bontemps is a senior NBA writer for ESPN.com who covers the league and…
Former Secretary of Housing and Urban Development Dr. Ben Carson, recently named National Nutrition Advisor at the U.S. Department of…
Federal employees and annuitants are heading into another year of sharp increases in their health insurance premiums, both under the…
A federal judge on Thursday (Oct. 9) dismissed Drake's defamation lawsuit against Universal Music Group over Kendrick Lamar's "Not Like…
10/9: CBS Morning News - CBS News Watch CBS News Israel and Hamas agree to first phase of Gaza peace…
New York Attorney General Letitia James speaks during a news conference January 8, 2025 in New York. Michael M. Santiago/Getty…