GOLDSTEIN: PM accusing prime ministers of dishonesty over carbon taxes is rich

Content of the article

Prime Minister Justin Trudeau accusing Manitoba Premier Heather Stefanson and other Premiers of being dishonest to Canadians about the impact of his carbon tax on the cost of living was pretty staggeringly hypocritical .

Advertisement 2

Content of the article

“What the Prime Minister and others across the country don’t seem to be honest with Canadians is that in places like Manitoba, where the federal price for pollution applies, average families get more “money from the price of pollution than the extra price on pollution is costing them,” Trudeau said Thursday, before a meeting with Stefanson.

Content of the article

“We’ve found a way to fight climate change while supporting families in need, and that’s something we’ll continue to do,” Trudeau said, as reported by The Canadian Press.

Trudeau was responding to a request from the premiers of Manitoba, Alberta and Saskatchewan to temporarily suspend the federal carbon tax to help people better deal with inflation. (Ontario is the fourth province where the Prime Minister has imposed his carbon tax.)

Advertisement 3

Content of the article

We apologize, but this video failed to load.

Trudeau’s claim that “average families” in these provinces receive more carbon tax rebates than they pay in carbon tax is based on his government’s claim that 80% of households end up getting out of it financially.

But in March, independent, nonpartisan Parliamentary Budget Officer Yves Giroux said that when you consider the negative financial impact of Trudeau’s carbon tax on the economy – including the reduction in annual GDP , labor income and business investment – 60% of households in the four provinces end up worse off financially.

That will rise to 80% in Ontario in 2024 and 80% in Alberta in 2028, the Parliamentary Budget Officer said.

“Most households in backstop provinces will see a net loss as a result of federal carbon pricing… That is, household carbon costs will exceed the action incentive payments for the climate that households will receive,” Giroux said.

Advertisement 4

Content of the article

We apologize, but this video failed to load.

The differences claimed by the Trudeau government in relation to the Parliamentary Budget Officer are surprising.

For this year, according to the Trudeau government, average Manitoba households will end up earning $229 after paying the federal carbon tax due to the rebates. By contrast, the Parliamentary Budget Officer says the average household in Manitoba will be $299 worse off.

In the other three provinces, the relative numbers are:

Alberta: Federal government says average household earns $338 better, Parliamentary Budget Officer says $671 less.

Saskatchewan: Federal government says average household earns $319, PBO $390 worse.

Ontario: Feds say average household gets off $134 better, PBO $360 less.

We apologize, but this video failed to load.

Remember, this is only for this year, with a carbon price of $50 per tonne of greenhouse gas emissions, which will increase annually to $170 in 2030.

Advertisement 5

Content of the article

As for public deception, before the 2019 election, the Trudeau government said its carbon price would be frozen at $50 a tonne from 2022 to 2030. After the election, the story changed.

Additionally, the Trudeau government has repeatedly asserted, beginning in 2016, that it will meet its 2020 emissions reduction target.

It missed its 2020 target by 57 million tonnes – the equivalent of all power sector emissions that year – even with the global recession caused by the pandemic reducing emissions worldwide.

Trudeau refused a request from the premiers of the four Atlantic premiers to extend his deadline for them to submit plans to the federal government on how they will price emissions through 2030, which expired on Friday.

Premiers had called for more time to implement measures to mitigate the inflationary impact of carbon pricing on their citizens.

[email protected]

Advertisement 1


Postmedia is committed to maintaining a lively yet civil discussion forum and encourages all readers to share their views on our articles. Comments can take up to an hour to be moderated before appearing on the site. We ask that you keep your comments relevant and respectful. We have enabled email notifications. You will now receive an email if you receive a reply to your comment, if there is an update to a comment thread you follow, or if a user follows you comments. See our Community Guidelines for more information and details on how to adjust your email settings.


Back to top button